There Is Plenty Of Innovation In The Startup Space, Time to Leverage It
If you’ve read the news over the last few weeks, you’ve probably seen the article on Walmart buying Jet.com for $3B. While it remains to be seen if the “marriage” will work, we are starting to see a shift in the way middle and major corporates see ups, maybe not as rivals, but as partners.
A new study on the state of startup/corporate collaboration from MassChallenge and imagination shows that not only are corporates more eager to work with startups, 23% see it as “mission critical, and 82% said it’s at least “somewhat important.”. Most importantly, 67% of those responded that they wanted to work with earlier stage startups. Source: Fortune
A long time ago, I used to work for a major movie theater chain who shall remain nameless. I assisted this chain in the development of tools to help manage their advertising spend across the country. They were the biggest theater chain in the country, and at the time they needed some very sophisticated algorithms to be built in order to properly allocate advertising spend between the exhibitor, distributor and the studios who produced the movies. At the time, I suggested that the company contract with an outside firm in order to assist in the tool development. After putting together a formal RFP, and going through a number of rounds of demos and meetings, we had settled on two companies: one a small scrappy startup which had a single product, laser-focused on exactly what we wanted. The other was a larger, older and bigger company which also had a solution, not as focused, but still pretty food. I distinctly remember sitting down with my manager to make the final decision between the two companies. I was more partial to the startup as I thought that they had the best solution and that it was focused exactly to our needs, and I liked the guys there more. The older company was OK as well. The prices were much higher from the older company, but they did have a broader experience. I figured that we would review the pros and cons of each company and pick the best solution together. He took one look at the names of each company on the hard copy presentations and without even opening them, selected the older, bigger company.
When I asked why he said only one thing:
Elephants only f**k other elephants
I’ve seen many cases of this over the years, companies preferring to work with bigger, similar companies for no other reason that the above, even though the startup solution might be better.
Times have changed. In fact, I’d almost suggest that things have done a complete 180 – now many major corporates prefer to work with startups, building partnerships where both companies can benefit, whether or not an M&A is in the cards. Startups can provide valuable insight into markets, technologies which are not tied to the corporates possibly older and less flexible systems, new, innovative ideas and partnerships which can open doors which may not have been there for the corporate.
In the past, I’ve talked about not innovating via acquihires, but that doesn’t mean that healthy partnerships can’t lead to win/win scenarios to both parties. There are many upsides to both parties in this kind of relationship:
- Access to new markets – one of Walmarts reasons for picking up Jet.com is access to Millenials, who don’t shop at Walmart.com. In a partnership, corporates can help fund or connect with startups to access untapped markets. For example, a bank could assist in funding a unique digital wallet startups , while running its back end infrastructure through the bank’s pipes, instead of through PayPal or Stripe, thus reducing costs for the startup
- Access to new technologies – while the corporate may be running their own servers on an older technology, the startup is more likely to be running on the cloud, using a newer, more modern stack. The corporate could leverage that code or technologies in their own product suite
- Access to great new ideas: I’ve held ideation sessions in the corporate world and in the startup world, and while both parties produce great results, it’s more difficult to tease out truly innovative ideas from most of the corporate folks. However, they have the strongest subject matter expertise. On the flipside, startups have more disruptive ideas but may not understand the legal, regulatory or industry limitations which the corporate knows all too well. The best solution: put them in a room together and the best ideas will flow. You can then divvy up who will tackle what, with each of you profiting from the exchange
- Access to partnerships: As above, if elephants only f**k other elephants, the same is true of mice. Startups may prefer to work with other startups, and hooking up with the right startup can help you build those partnerships as well.
While it’s important to innovate from within, you need a good balance from both external and internal sources in order to tap the full spectrum of innovation.